Christa Cotton: Cocktail Recipes by El Guapo

Just in time for summer, these cocktail recipes from El Guapo Bitters, Tonics & Syrups are here to beat the heat. El Guapo is the subject of “Shaking Things Up.”

By Derek Herscovici ’14

El Guapo logo

Just in time for summer, these cocktail recipes from El Guapo Bitters, Tonics & Syrups are here to beat the heat. El Guapo is the subject of “Shaking Things Up,” a profile of 2011 alumna Christa Cotton in the Summer 2020 issue of Auburn Magazine. The founder and CEO of New Orleans Beverage Group and owner of El Guapo Bitters, Tonics & Syrups, Cotton has earned widespread acclaim for her New Orleans-inspired cocktail line.

Made with locally sourced ingredients that are traceable to the farm level or third-party certified organic. El Guapo’s entire line is non-GMO, high fructose corn syrup free, gluten free and vegetarian, too.

Visit El Guapo’s website for their products and more recipes. Cheers!

Jungle Bird Milk Punch
Makes one cocktail
• 2 oz Zero Proof Clarified Milk Punch (recipe below)
• 2 oz white rum (we used Roulaison)
• 2 oz El Guapo® Spiced Pecan Syrup
• 1 T. El Guapo® Polynesian Kiss Bitters
• Edible or yard flowers, as garnish

In a clean shaker filled with ice, add clarified milk punch, rum, syrup, and bitters. Shake until well chilled. Strain into a low ball and serve up, using edible flowers or yard flowers as garnish. Cheers!

Holiday Old Fashioned (Featuring Good Food Award winning Chicory Pecan Bitters)
Makes one cocktail
• 3 oz bourbon (we used @13thcolony)
• .5 oz El Guapo® Spiced Pecan Syrup
• 8 dashes El Guapo® Holiday Pie Bitters
• 1 large rock
• 2 Luxardo cherries, yard flowers and leaves, to garnish

In a lowball, combine bitters, syrup & bourbon. Stir to combine & place one large rock in glass. Garnish with cherries & any other desired accoutrements. We chose yard flowers & a tropical leaf… because optimism.

Desert Island Margaritas
Makes 2 cocktails
• 2.5 oz Coconut Tequila (@1800tequila)
• 1 oz Triple Sec
• 1.5 oz guava purée
• 1.5 oz Pink Coconut Water (@harmlessharvest)
• 1.5 oz key lime juice
• 4 dashes El Guapo® Polynesian Kiss Bitters (@elguapobitters)

Rim glass with Lime flavored sugar using a lime wedge. Regular sugar works too! Add a few large cubes of ice. Pour all ingredients straight into glass, stir, squeeze in lime wedge and add it or discard, top with bitters.\

Rose Cordial Cocktail
Makes one cocktail
• 1.5 oz gin (Have you tried Wonderbird?)
• .74 oz El Guapo® Rose Cordial
• .5oz @lillet Blanc

• .5oz freshly squeezed lemon juice
• Topo Chico
• Dried rose petals (or rose petal tea!), for garnish

In a clean shaker filled with ice, add gin, cordial, Lillet & juice. Shake until well chilled. * strain into a collins glass. Top with Topo Chico & garnish with dried rose petals.

Pro tip: you can find dried rose petals in some loose-leaf teas as well as sold as an individual garnish!

Sweet & Sour Citrus Martini
Makes one cocktail 
• 1 oz El Guapo® Lemon Cordial
• 1 tsp El Guapo® Cuban Bitters
• .5 oz freshly squeezed Meyer lemon juice
• .5 oz freshly squeezed orange juice
• .5 oz vodka (we used St. Roch, but any quality vodka will do)

• Sugar, Meyer lemon peel or yard flowers, for garnish

In a shaker filled with ice, combine Lemon Cordial, bitters, juices & vodka. Shake until well chilled. Rim a martini glass in sugar (rim with water first to help sugar adhere) before straining liquid into the glass. Garnish with a Meyer lemon peel or yard flowers before serving.

Pro tip: For a more prominently bitter martini, add a tablespoon of Cuban bitters as opposed to a teaspoon.

El Guapo and an Oldfashioned cocktail on a beach